There are solar storm events which can induce faster timescale geomagnetic distances. Primarily the x-ray and EUV light from the solar flares themselves ionizing the upper atmosphere and the currents resulting from that. But to have a bright enough flare to do that in a damaging way would require an exceptionally large active region. So large you'd be seeing it with the naked eye on Earth before things went down.
Another fast timescale solar caused geomagnetic disturbance can happen from relativistic "sudden energetic particles" sometimes directed at Earth. But generally the amount of energy in these particles is minor compared to the component in the flare light (~2/3 on average) versus the CME if one happens (~1/3).
So, no. It wouldn't immediately knock out society. Especially with solar panels everywhere. But it would knock out the power grid for at least 2 months before new transformers could be built and installed. That might take down society.
Given how reliant we are on electricity and the internet I don't think it's actually a stretch to say it would be a society ending event.
A more realistic scenario is that GIC would result in grid instability by causing protective relays to "trip" offline. Enough grid infrastructure tripping in succession could produce a cascading failure and widespread blackouts on a large grid. As seen in the 2003 Northeast blackout[2], it can take days to recover from such an event.
[1] https://library.e.abb.com/public/cbd31097f5bd26bfc1257b16002...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northeast_blackout_of_2003
There is two things that puts my mind at ease.
1. Our electrical infrastructure, while flimsy in some ways is a lot more resilient than we take for granted. It is said the power grid fails in theory but works in practice. But given forward warning, it is possible to shut off or limit the energy flow prior to the event - it will mean voluntary blackouts for a few hours but it is better than a forced blackout for a few months.
2. The forward warning is actually really good now even being up to 2-3 days in advance, just look to any Aurora prediction site, we are all over tracking this stuff. For all the fear of a repeat Carrington event, we would know it is coming and deal with it.
The last few years have shown that leadership in certain areas has Cluster B personality traits, and will do the opposite of good advice just because it feels good to be contrarian.
There's been many a time when some large sequence of strong CME come and everyone expects intense geomagnetic activity but there's no -Bz so it just buffets things for a bit and causes auroral oval effects. Whereas other times some small lone barely CME will arrive with 7 hours of -20nT Bz and causes 45N aurora.
What I'm saying is that the people in charge of chosing to shut down parts of the grid are not ever going to get a confident assertion that damage will happen if they don't. There will be enough uncertainty that this kind of pre-emptive action days in advance will not happen.
At best we'll get a few hours of time to mitigate when the events arrive at L1 and the solar monitoring spacecraft there like ACE give actual warning.