However, both assume a well intented and agreed upon implicit goal of looking for the best way to teach science.
I do not think the politics pushing for the changes described in the article share that goal.
However, both assume a well intented and agreed upon implicit goal of looking for the best way to teach science.
I do not think the politics pushing for the changes described in the article share that goal.
We have a pretty decent history of being relatively early adopters of evidence-based changes to our education system in New Zealand. That's reflected in, for example, the high desirableness of New Zealand-trained educators in the prestigious international-school circuit.
What do you think the politics is pushing for?
The postmodern curriculum theorists influencing these ideas are fundamentally anti-science.
They criticize presence and origin, they deny that there is a inherent truth behind phenomena, criticize the idea that anything is really there, really exists, or can be directly apprehended if it does exist. Furthermore they see the natural sciences itself as product of the social relations that they serve to judge, that is,the idea was created at a certain time and place, to serve certain interests, and is dependent on a certain intellectual and social context, specifically one that that serves the "status-quo" of patriarchal oppression maintained through an active process of "exclusion, opposition, and hierarchization" that is inevitably embedded in the scientific method itself.
The "situating" and "holistic" approach, while in theory neutral, is in practice presented to facilitate the introduction of relationalism, placing "power and suppression" as the fundamental paradigm in which to contextualize every element of the curriculum and the teaching interactions.
The choice of current contexts with far from more settled science and and highly divisive narratives is no accident, meant to deconstruct and displace science rather than convey it.
Also, this looks like a very early draft designed to incorporate feedback.
I don’t understand how people go about criticizing a deliberately iterative process based on the first draft.
As for 'evidence', the presented framework, objectives and tactics come straight out of postmodern curriculum theorist literature. They would see nothing controversial in the above.
You could argue that the proposed drafts do not intentionally align with the presented ideological framework, but are merely accidentally aligned or enabeling. Not sure that would make it better.