The Case Against Judicial Review
prospect.org
prospect.org
Judicial review is not a problem, lack of judicial accountability—arising from structural duopoly, large supermajority requirement for conviction on impeachment, and judicial tenure limited only by impeachment—is the problem.
All of the examples the author gives on judicial review being a major, undemocratic problem (Dredd Scott, Plessy, Santa Clara v. Southern Pacific Railroad, even Marbury v. Madison) come at times when Congress and the President are unable to come to a decision themselves due to partisan gridlock and infighting.
In times where the government is able to act effectively, the supreme court doesn't institute controversial decisions. The real problem is partisan gridlock—judicial overreach is just a symptom, not a cause of our current problems.