Airship Tails
neil.fraser.name
neil.fraser.name
[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beechcraft_Bonanza [2]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robin_ATL
They also both use mechanical control mixers. This is a diagram of the Robin mixer - http://i.imgur.com/yVLQA.jpg
The Bonanza was first flown in the late forties.
I'd imagine that the choice to use fly by wire on the Zeppelin NT was more to do with the logistics of routing control cables to the fins, rather than because of complexities in manual control. On that sort of scale, a fly by wire system is going to save you a fair amount of weight in control wiring and brackets, and makes the gondola system far more flexible.
This is like saying that no human could hope to catch a ball flying through the air because it would require doing ballistic calculations in one's head.
I think the author should investigate the combination of control surface manipulations needed to make a coordinated turn in an aircraft, or doing a crosswind landing.
Or if he really wants to have is mind blown: how helicopters are flown.
I hear I'm not alone.
In my case, I was being taught by people who taught using techniques appropriate for an audience who thought in similar ways to them. I don't. When I finally found a technique that suited the way I think, and the things I already can do, suddenly I found I wasn't bad at languages - I was actually pretty good! But it was too late to gain real proficiency, and I no longer have the time I had in school to work on it. So I get by, rueing the lost opportunity.
But I've since honed my ideas into ways of teaching other stuff to people who think similarly to me, and who want to learn something quickly. I can teach you to juggle in 2 hours. Or teach you to unicycle in 2 hours. I wonder if I could teach you (the underlying rudamentary requirements of) how to drive in 2 hours.
Probably not - driving is more complex than either unicycling or juggling - but I bet the same ideas would work. Wish there was a way to test this.
0_0 you UNDERSTAND.
The author spent some effort to build a joystick to demonstrate to us how the problem could be solved. I would think it appropriate you spend some time researching your point of view, maybe with a quick model in X-Plane. We will all be richer for what you find.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mMvLuUJFHYk
If someone insists that it is 'straightforward' I'm left to conclude that either they're a very experienced pilot who has been doing it for so long that it's difficult for them to remember what it was like to learn, or they don't have an understanding of what's involved.
Consider this: You're flying an airplane. The elevators are trimmed to maintain level flight. Now you turn the yolk to deflect the ailerons, and the aircraft rolls. In this rolled state--say we're rolled 20 degrees from vertical--the elevators are no longer horizontal. They're 20 degrees off the horizontal meaning their force is no longer 100% pitch. It's now a combination of pitch and yaw. Firstly this means that they're no longer trimmed properly to maintain level flight and the aircraft will begin to pitch, secondly they are now causing the plane to yaw into the turn. So now you have to bring the rudder into the equation to compensate for the elevators, but it's also no longer a 100% yaw control surface, it now affects both pitch and yaw and you are left with a situation which should look very similar to that in the Zeppelin NT.
Describing the problem of coordinated flight, you end up with calculations which would be quite difficult to do by hand, and one might conclude that "no human" could hope to pull it off while sitting in a cockpit. Yet it is something humans can not only do, but with a bit of practice can do without even having to try very hard, by learning to "feel" the aircraft.
I think the author's joystick is neat and I congratulate him for making it. My only point is that the author errs in saying that "no human" could directly handle the Zeppelin NT's control surfaces. I think is error is not in overestimating the complexity of the problem but in underestimating the human ability to handle such problems.
Relevant article: http://www.airships.net/farmers-blimp
edit: the currently mountain view based blimp's official site, http://www.airshipventures.com/
But I think it's not accurate to think of the Zeppelin NT as a blimp with some rigid parts. The original Zeppelins had non-rigid fabric gas chambers as well, hung from a duralumin frame which also supported the airfoils and helped the fuselage maintain shape.
The gas chambers of a Zeppelin NT support their own shape through positive pressure, as in a blimp. But they don't have to also support the airfoils, etc. For that, the vessel has a rigid composite structure.
So I think it's more accurate to describe the Zeppelin NT as "a rigid airship with self-supporting gas chambers." And I see no reason why the design could not be scaled up to Graf Zeppelin or Hindenburg size if economics permitted it.
Well, yes. He said "this is a Zeppelin, not a blimp", which is a lot like saying "this is a Chevy, not a butterfly". A blimp built by Zeppelin would still be a Zeppelin, and Zeppelin builds all sorts of things that aren't related to airships.
The reason I don't think it will scale well is, like a blimp, pressurization of the gas bag is what keeps a hybrid in the proper shape. This means as the size of the airship increases the envelop pressure must also increase to deal with greater external forces, making the lifting gas heavier and therefor less efficient.
The US navy fielded blimps larger than the Hindenburg until the early '60s, but they were never able to get more than about half the Hindenburg's lift capability for this reason.
With a hybrid you still get the benefit of placing engine pods more efficiently and you don't have to worry about the nose collapsing if you go too fast. However, if you were going to go through the trouble and expense of building an 800 ft airship there's no reason to sacrifice that much lift.
Quite a shock to see one of the Airship Industry Airships parked at Cranfield when I got to work one morning
I'd be interesting in the mathematical details myself. Computer-reliant optimizations are so interesting. . .
I still regret letting my parents give away my meccano collection. It's fantastic for quickly prototyping usable things.
Check out http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h0S4tOd3A0k (James May's Toy Stories episode covering Meccano)