I'd advise OP to keep #1 going: As a fledgling company you don't want to waste time time on the kind of person who sticks a 2x4 in their bike tire and then yells at you for not being more accomodating.

The light chasing affect before each page load is hopefully a bug (it's ok to show that once, but every page change gets old)

Overall clearly the site is incomplete, I think OP should go through the site on Chrome and Safari and clean up the broken links. I suspect OP wanted a brutal review of their core offering (ie we'd put in API links)

Unfortunately it's not easy to get people to do that OP: You're asking for API access without showing what the product does. I'd move your screenshot of a terminal up as a hero image (for inspiration: https://www.warp.dev/warp-ai) and hopefully you'll get a better conversion rate to actually trying it out.

Also maybe a creative "cheat" here, OpenAI plugins require publicly accessible APIs. Maybe instead of asking people for their own schema, offer reviews of the publically available plugin APIs (which there are a ton of)