I’m not commenting on your theory, but what I love about HN is that, for the most part, people comment purely to talk about a topic. There’s very little self promotion. It’s very nice.
I don't understand why you are classifying as "sideswipes" posts in a "Show HN" where others chime in to "Show HN".
I mean, "Show HN" is about showing and discussing stuff, not a pulpit to worship a submitter.
I guess it tracks as well, in general on the internet I find you get better advice claiming something is the case and then getting corrected than just asking for advice