I kept hitting an issue where random things on the internet would stop working: USPS's login page, my WiFi garage door opener, etc.
I finally tracked the problem down to bright cloud flagging my home IP as a "proxy". We went back and forth for a while, and the one thing they eventually showed me was a number of subdomains for things I no longer had online (such as a gitlab instance), that now got the default Nginx Proxy Manager "success" page. (I have a wildcard subdomain set up, so it continues to resolve even after I take something down.)
It turns out that brightcloud's crawler just flags any page with the word "proxy" on it - it doesn't distinguish between a reverse proxy and the open forward proxies that their customers actually care about.
I switched the configuration to serve up a 404 for unrecognized domains/subdomains and haven't had a problem since.