I know, crazy, right? It’s like what if we actually honored the 4th amendment.
I know, crazy, right? It’s like what if we actually honored the 4th amendment.
Buy and publish all congress members location data for a long enough period and I think you'll get your wish.
Which part of the 4th amendment is being violated by the government in this case?
US courts have widely ruled that data a that a third party collects/generates/maintains on a person does not fall under the 4th amendment. Many other western countries have actually decided the opposite, that you have a privacy right in data about you.
Personally I think US interpretation is wrong and inconsistent with the 4th amendment. Congress could easily settle the issue wrt federal law enforcement.
edit: Example
https://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2016/08/21/new-mass-gantri...
https://gizmodo.com/e-zpass-is-the-best-tracking-device-that...
It’s public information if a law enforcement officer happens to see you in public. It’s not public information if their surveillance is via a 3rd party whose information is not public.
Arguably even if you’re in public, surveillance (looking for you specifically) should require a warrant. We could debate that.
I think if you try to define what was interpreted by "papers" in a pre-digital context you would conclude it is sufficiently analogous to many things in our modern world. By "papers" they likely meant diaries, personal mail, accounting logs, ship manifests, personal inventories, order histories, receipts for travel. All things which may have been written down on a piece of paper which are now logged on our phones.
If you take an originalist argument that the constitution is static and cannot be reinterpreted/amended you have to first justify why you think amendments like the banning of slavery or women's voting rights amendments are not legitimate in the United States. We certainly have a culture of defining rights which our predecessors did not explicitly call out in the early years of its history. Even male suffrage (non-land owning males) in the late 19th century was a revolutionary step in the definition and expansion of citizens rights.
Considering data digital as papers is perfectly reasonable but the government still isn't searching or seizures your papers. They're buying someone elses "papers".
Why wouldn’t this apply to metadata about you? It’s just as much your information as the results of a cholesterol test.
So culturally we do think they should be even if the legal system disagrees.
The Supreme Court has uses a narrower definition. That’s doesn’t mean they are correct but the justice system isn’t actually based on the constitution directly it’s based on past rulings by the Supreme Court.
My bringing up HIPPA was simply pointing out that even though the legal system doesn’t protect them based on the 4th, it does protect them. Further the reason this part of HIPPA exists is the same reason the 4th was written.
Holy straw man Batman! What kind of crazy "originalist" believes the constitution can't be amended? There's a literal provision in the constitution for amending the constitution!
Originalism just means you don't use the courts to invent new rights out of thin air, or nullify rights you don't agree with, not that you can't amend the constitution at all. And even by originalist standards I don't think interpreting "papers" to include digital records is a stretch, anymore than interpreting "press" to include blog posts is.