The real issue here is that privatisation was and is a political football instead of a practical policy.
Should the government run coal mines at a loss which have no strategic value just to keep jobs? No.
Should the government run natural monopolies in strategic or socially important areas (like railways, water utilities, etc)? Yes.
But instead what started at privatising the former turned into an ideological push to privatise the later.
There is also the question of HOW these services should be run...