Comment by brvsft | Hacker News Reader

Comment by brvsft | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

It's infuriating to see such a stupid take bubbled up to the top replies to the top comment on this post.

Why would a singer know what Microsoft Excel is? And how exactly is her response even "pride[ful]" ignorance? She just said she doesn't know what it is and therefore doesn't care about the memes. Which part here is pride in her ignorance of software mostly used in the accounting profession?

I'm not going to say she's a genius, but it's grounded for a person to acknowledge when they don't know what something is and don't give a shit. This thing was an afterthought to a music video for a song she was in. The video is tangential to her actual work. Why should she care? If you're going to call her ignorant and stupid for it, you should be able to explain why she should care about Microsoft Excel specifically when it's presented to her in a flurry of internet memes.

Also, why is she on TV? Because she's the second most famous person who was in Destiny's Child, behind Beyonce. Is TV only supposed to show people of high intelligence? Are "stupid" people actually subhumans who should not be represented on television, the bastion of idiots? Are stupid people actually morally bad and smart people are morally good? I'm so confused about all the things your worldview could imply. It's nonsense.

I don't think that the commenter expected her to know Excel, but the tone of her response especially where she started saying "I don't care" can be reasonably interpreted as dismissive and defensive to the point of being proud, which is really odd because it's not like people are blaming her for the production crew's mistake?

Not knowing computers at this day and age (or whenever that video was shot which seems recent) is not a cool thing to celebrate, because the most basic computer skills are now as important as knowing how to drive. But I really think that more than a criticism of her intelligence, people really are criticizing her character. She could have handled this more gracefully by laughing it off, because it is laughable.

> because the most basic computer skills are now as important as knowing how to drive

Maybe not knowing how to *drive*, lots of people don't need to know that, but it's kind of up there with knowing how to read.

I don't care about Kelly Rowland Excel memes either. Good reason to lash out at someone you don't know?

> because the most basic computer skills are now as important as knowing how to drive.

This is the best comparison used because like knowing how to drive not everyone needs to know basic computer skills, so thanks for backing up OP and Kelly. o7

It would only be a good comparison if 90 percent of jobs in the US required you to drive as part of the job.

I'll argue that, in 2023, the most basic 'computer' skills are knowing how to:

* buy a smartphone (okay, not even a skill)

* connect to the internet

* visit a website

* install an app

* use basic apps, e.g. read/send email, read/send text messages, view/take photos

That's it. And none of this is necessary for survival, nor to even be what I'd call a well-rounded person. They're just modern conveniences. Things beyond this are trainable. People get bonus points for knowing how to use 2FA or spot phishing attempts or other scams, but I view this is going beyond the purview of basic computer skills into basic cybersecurity.

So I don't see not knowing what Excel is as equivalent to not 'knowing computers.' But you know what, why do you get to choose what is a 'cool thing' to celebrate? If someone chooses to be computer illiterate and celebrates it, why is that a problem? My wife doesn't know how to drive. Guess what, she'll never murder someone with a car. Kudos to her.

Excel is a ubiquitous tool with many applications for life in the information age so don’t even take this out of context and argue about life situations in the Stone Age.

If you’ve ever tried managing your own finances in a seriously methodical manner, for example, and you should, then using Excel or alternative spreadsheet software simply would be inevitable. Are you saying that managing your own finances is not an important life skill, let alone a chore? Should anyone be proud at all that they don’t? Heck, she has achieved some success as an artist so she must have money to manage and understand. Even rich people who have businesses to run must deal with Excel on a regular basis, because not doing so is gross neglect and can have serious consequences, both financially and legally.

I don’t understand why you’re so hellbent on defending ignorance, to be honest. If you’re not aware, you should know that you went a really long way to defend not knowing Excel, to think that for Kelly Rowland herself, I only criticised her tone.

I love spreadsheets, and I use them all the time, even in my personal life. Not once did I state that Excel sucks, is unimportant and shitty software, that no one should know it, or that people should have poor financial habits. I am not "defending ignorance." I have literally taken university-level accounting courses out of personal interest, despite not being an accountant by profession. (Although, I tend to use Google Sheets more because it's free and still functions well.)

What I am defending is someone saying that they don't know what Microsoft Excel is and don't care and having other people refer to that as prideful ignorance.

How can you be so blind to the worldview of people outside your bubble and be so proud of it ?

Exactly yesterday,I was helping a friend at the end of a workshop on accounting for entrepreneurs in social sectors.

To wrap up the two days class, he asked them what they had learned.

To my surprise a good number of them said they had learned making a simple formula in excel cells. ( white , 20-something , males, just in case you were wondering ).

There is a big world out there full of normal people that don't have the faintest idea about things you consider basic skills.

Excel isn't a ubiquitous tool outside of your world buddy. Any rich person isn't worried about their finances most of that stuff is delegated to a financial advisor so I don't know what you're talking about.

To be honest, “I don’t care” seems to be the most reasonable/sensible thing anyone said in this situation so far.

> the tone of her response especially where she started saying "I don't care" can be reasonably interpreted as dismissive and defensive to the point of being proud

I interpret the "I don't care" as "that's pedantic" and "I have more important things to focus on".

This is a perfectly valid take. Calling it stupid doesn't make yours any more valid.

> Why would a singer know what Microsoft Excel is

To make sure they don't get ripped off by their producer/label

If a music producer starts showing you Excel spreadsheets you need to fire their ass

You know that most musicians didn't start off as professional musicians, right?

I can't imagine there's anyone who lives in a sufficiently technologically-literate world that they know how to use a mobile phone, and despite this has never heard of the second most commonly used bit of software in the workplace.

Worth noting that while most musicians don’t “start off” as professional musicians, Rowland entered the game back in the 90s and was basically just a kid when destiny’s child was formed. Leaves little time to learn anything else besides the ins and outs of the industry I’d think.

> Leaves little time to learn anything else besides the ins and outs of the industry I’d think.

Yeah, in the music industry it's not like you ever have to deal with massive lists of numbers.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com