Thinkcomp, I agree with almost everything you say about the economics of the legal profession, but I think you miss out on something crucial.
Before I went to law school, I unconsciously thought of law as a branch of engineering: Learn the rules, twist the right dials, and things will happen as you expect. That was naive. Law does have rules, and dials to twist, but for socio-political reasons I won't go into here, the rules and dials aren't tightly locked to outcomes. As a result, law has long struck me as being more akin to weather-guessing than to engineering.