To be clear: you tried to say "C offers encapsulation/isolation". People read "This solution is equivalent to 'private'", an almost completely unrelated statement, and then respond to that.
That could typically be classified as a "Straw man fallacy"[0], but I believe people who do this in many cases simply do not have the necessary reading skills to understand what proposition has been made, and therefore honestly believe themselves to be reasoning correctly (i.e. without fallacy).
Reading comprehension used to be a topic at school when I was a child. I suppose that's no longer the case??