IL Top Court: Compelling Password Production Isn’t a Fifth Amendment Violation
techdirt.com
techdirt.com
> Although the denial did not directly suppress specifically identified evidence, it prevented the State from accessing any evidence on the phone and presenting it to the factfinder, thereby having the substantive effect of suppressing evidence.
This... seems like some weird mental / legal gymnastics.
In the decision linked in the article, the court says that putting in your passcode is just muscle memory; you don’t have to dig deep into your mind for it.
It also said that phones are just containers and that a defendant has valid 4th amendment rights to challenge the scope of the search warrant. So I guess they are saying the just because you unlocked the phone doesn’t mean the police can do whatever they want with it.
Same way growing extra grain, that you don't intend to sell anyone is still regulable by the Federal government as interstate commerce.
See Wickett v. Filburn