It just doesn’t seem aligned with the principles of a republic or democracy to have unelected lifetime members who are able to draft legislation.
It just doesn’t seem aligned with the principles of a republic or democracy to have unelected lifetime members who are able to draft legislation.
FYI, the House of Lords can't reject the same bill more than three times, and can't reject a bill that calls an election, so its undemocraticness isn't as bad as you might assume.
There are many issues with it but I don't think many of them are much worse than those that already exist with the House of Commons. (Lobbying: exists in both. Unelectedness: the first past the post system is pretty bad here too. Ability of unelected people to introduce bills: private members' bills exist too).
All of these are problems I'd like solved but I wouldn't support removing the House of Lords.
it acts as a brake for controversial legislation, which is generally a good thing