So now we build a shiny new factory, but are we getting the best and brightest from our now-competition to help us get it up and running? Of course not.
The expertise of offshoring is often a one way street, and once the people that knew are gone they are gone. It takes a few years to get a factory running well from scratch without the kind of experience and domain knowledge that can’t be obtained from education alone.
It’s hardly turnkey. Every process has its idiosyncratic interactions with other processes, whether it is variability in feedstocks, interactive variability in various product stages, getting the bugs worked out of a newly installed machine, buggy intersystem comms, structural vibration of the factory structure itself, process timing to deal with those vibration issues, etc etc etc etc.
The overall system complexity of even a modest modern factory is orders of magnitude above say, 1940s style manufacturing which is what most people visualise when they think of a factory.
Manufacturing is really hard. Getting good at it requires a lot of hands-on experience. China (and Japan before them) didn't just Xerox a bunch of American knowledge and become world-class manufacturing economies overnight; it took decades of investment and hard work to build up a skills base. If America wants to reverse the decline of their manufacturing sector, it'll take an equally determined effort.
Sorry, what? What are you saying knowledge is, then?
As many experienced people will tell you, Murphy's law is a bitch.
> understanding of or information about a subject that you get by experience or study, either known by one person or by people generally
https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/knowledg...
So if I don't know something by experiencing it or studying it, what other way is there? Skills and understanding fall under those two.
For example, as a builder, you'd quickly understand two pieces of wood are the same, that's something which requires skills to work around, not just knowledge. Maybe it's better to say applied knowledge?
Recently I've moved areas, and the type of cedar I get here is a little bit different to the type of cedar I get out west. It feels different to work with, and it's a bit of an art not to damage it. My previous knowledge didn't really prepare me for this.
As a machinist, I rely a great deal on intuition. I can hear a bad cut across the room. I couldn't tell you exactly what it is that I'm listening for, but I can tell just by sound that a cutting insert is worn out or that the feeds and speeds aren't quite right. When I look at a drawing to plan out a sequence of cutting operations, I'm balancing dozens of parameters and thousands of subtle factors to achieve a suitable compromise between material removal rate, process stability, tool wear, energy consumption, precision and complexity. I can teach you all of the facts that I'm weighing up, but I can't fully explain all of the heuristics and instincts that guide that process of optimisation.
Essentially all production machining is done with automated CNC machines, but most apprentices still start out learning on manually-operated machines. There are things you learn by standing at a machine and turning the handwheels that nobody knows how to teach.
There's quite a lot to know, and the speed of learning is limited. Answers to advanced questions which you are ready to provide must be met by the actual questions from the student, which must first form in their head as a result of processing the previous servings of knowledge.
Also, we teach thousands of years of experience in mathematics within the scope of 10-20 years.
The problem isn't that you can't teach 20 years of experience in a year - you can. The problem is that this knowledge isn't stored anywhere that's easily accessible and that makes propagation next to impossible.
There's stuff like weapons where the knowhow is truly gone. So the DoD has to reverse engineer the remaining artifacts and attempt to recreate the entire stack.
Tim Cook is one of the highest compensated CEOs in the world. In his best years he’s paid something like $100M all-in.
Apple has around 165,000 employees. Dividing up half his salary amongst them would be about $300 each.
If you can cherry pick, then I can too. Rivian's CEO made $422,140,679 in 2021, and they have 14,122 employees, so half that salary divided by number of employees comes out to $14,946 per employee. Not a bad bump in pay especially if you're in a factory putting together car parts.
The CEO of "Lucid Group, Inc." made $565,591,512 in 2021 and they had 7,200 employees, so the figure there is $39,277 per employee. Trust me, Peter Rawlinson will do just fine making only $282,795,756 per year.
The CEO of "Bright Health Group, Inc." makes $180,813,849 per year and they employ 1500 people - split in half and distributed to the employees they would get a pay bump of $60,271 per year.
So yeah. You can cherry-pick all you want, but the fact is that CEO pay is too damned high, and it's no wonder people don't want to go slave away in factories making a few dollars while the CEOs can afford 3 mega yachts and 12 vacation homes.
Re: Bright Health Group, similarly a one-time incentive grant which will likely end up around $0 given the firm’s struggles.
I’m not claiming all CEO pay is wise, of course. But “take 50% of CEO pay and redistribute it to the workers” wouldn’t move any needles.
Satya Nadella can surely afford a few nice yachts at this point, but in aggregate Microsoft handed out $7.5 billion(!!) in stock to its employees last year. His $55M was a drop in the bucket, and given what he’s done for those employees’ stock over the past decade I’d think they’d consider pay like that a bargain at twice the price.
Possibly the current approaches to AI can be used in these areas. But I'm afraid we're very much not there yet.
Nevertheless, even with all the blueprints at their disposal, early American-manufactured 75s were inferior to their French counterparts. It took a personal visit of the senior French engineers in the US plants to correct various subtle flaws in the manufacturing process.
Experience counts.
Arguably, nowadays, with cheap recording devices everywhere, it is easier than before to produce comprehensive documentation even for such activities that are hard to write down.