EVs Fall Much Shorter of EPA Estimates Than Gas Cars in Our Real-World Testing
caranddriver.com
caranddriver.com
For range estimate they should just use maximum highway speed. This is the worst case for EVs, and also what matters most in practice. City driving is the easy case for EVs.
Having said that, their highway testing seems less "real-world" than the EPA tests, driving at exactly 75mph for hours at a time?
Most drivers in an ICE car can get pretty close to the EPA fuel economy in the real world, but in EVs there are some pretty wild swings. Some EVs outperform their EPA number and others can't achieve it, making the EPA number not especially helpful.
>One reason the paper suggests for why EVs fail to match expectations is how the range is calculated. While separate city and highway range figures are computed behind closed doors, only a combined number is presented to consumers. The combined rating is weighted 55 percent in favor of the city figure, where EVs typically perform better. This inflates the range estimates, making it harder to match in real-world highway driving. The paper proposes publishing both city and highway range figures—as with fuel-economy estimates for gas-powered vehicles—to give shoppers a more holistic sense of a vehicle's abilities.
The problem is that measuring range in a city is nonsense. People only travel long distances on highways. This is no surprise: that's what they're built for. Efficiency matters in a city because most driving happens in the city. Range matters on the highway because most long-distance driving happens on the highway.