Had a similar thing happen. It was later in the day, really hot, on a weekend, with high humidity and a crying baby in the house. My regular A/C company was closed, so I called another one. The person quickly diagnosed the issue and said he could "fix it for $450. I just wanted it fixed so decided to let him do it. But he then started acting shady, so I told him I'd take a picture of the old part before he offered to "dispose of it safely". He didn't seem to quite like that. I figured out why: it turns out it was a $15 capacitor. Oh well, lesson learned.
If he at least said, "look, it's $250 to come after hours", I wouldn't have minded that, maybe he had a crying baby at home too. But he made it sound like the part was expensive and I was "extremely lucky" he just happen to have this unique and special part in his truck. And then, to make it worse, he installed the capacitor without taking it out of the cardboard box it came with. That would have ensured the capacitor would overheat soon enough, so I, as sucker would be calling him again. Pretty sneaky. I opened the unit the next day and installed the part properly and filed a complaint with the Better Business Bureau.