And whenever I read comments like yours, I facepalm. Accusations of astroturfing? Preaching about 'love and marriage' at a strip club? Really? Was there a sale on straw men?
His argument and examples are flimsy, and his sense of entitlement is implicit to the argument because he pirates what he could afford but doesn't feel like paying for. I'm not alone in having pointed out the problems with his argument and the petulant nature of his tone which leads to these conclusions.
I'm only saying that considering the tone of the post, I would never expect to make much money off of this kind of 'potential consumer'. I'm fairly convinced he'll find another excuse to pirate or another demand to make even if I met all of his. He basically admits to pirating 'World of Goo', a DRM free indie game, because 'It is not worth 20 dollars'.
Let me reiterate this a different way - a game that took a team of two indie devs[1] just under a year worth of effort to create, which they released without DRM[2], is not worth the price of a decent dinner to this guy. Nevermind that it will provide several hours of entertainment, it's not worth the price of a few starbucks coffees. But the devs understood that, so they went and had a 'Pay What You Want' sale[3] wherein you could have paid them as little as $0.01. About 17k did. It seems if this guy was allowed to set his own price, he'd be in that demographic, meaning that entire market would have been catered to for a net profit of about $170 dollars.
There are better target demographics than people with his level of entitlement - I won't waste my time. What I learned from their sale is that a periodic sale at a price point around 10 - 25% of standard will result in a lot of sales to people that might not have purchased otherwise. That is who I would try and target.
Also, Valve increased revenue twelvefold with their free to play route because they implemented a system that got people who had already bought the game to continue spending money on it - and the serious fan base already built up around the game ensured that they had people that would. The initial run of people who were willing to pay for the game as it stood was mostly over. They are not really comparable cases, and to try and make such a case apply to all games is a generalization that does not apply.
[1] http://2dboy.com/about.php [2] http://arstechnica.com/gaming/news/2008/10/world-of-goo-devs... [3] http://mashable.com/2009/10/20/world-of-goo-huge-success/