I'm too pragmatic about these things to try and advocate anything for the consumer other than ask that they pay for their games. I'm not asking the FBI to kick down their door. I'm asking consumers to understand exactly what it is they are doing when they pirate. After all, it's not like the internet just generated a random bytestream that happened to be a game they like - a group of developers took years hand crafting that data. Respect that, or don't, but don't claim moral high ground, or even equal footing.
My goal as a game developer is to make games that people will want to play and then make them available to as many people as possible who are willing to pay something reasonable for it as a means of compensating me for my efforts and helping to ensure I might be able to make more games in the future. That is all.