Depending on the organization, by the time it got to you, there may have already been discussions about scope and business need.
Unless you're an SME, your evaluation of what is needed is not better than that of those who are requesting the work. Sure, your knowledge of the effort is better, but that's not the same thing.
There's a decent chance you're going to come across as difficult to work with and then you're going to build a solution that doesn't fully meet their needs.
I get where you're coming from, but I've spent time on the other side. Requirements take negotiation and collaboration.