Have We Gotten Dark Matter All Wrong?
nautil.us
nautil.us
All the efforts to spot such an interaction seem to be based purely on wishing that it is not true, so that fancy expensive detectors can defensibly be promoted and somebody might get a prize. It seems of a piece with string theory. Maybe astrophysics, like particle physics, has lost its way, and needs to return to investigating phenomena that answer to experiment. Solar photosphere physics has yet to be elucidated in any detail. Jupiter's liquid-electrolyte moons orbit well within its magnetosphere. And planetary nebulae favor a long axis parallel to the galactic plane. Lots of crunchy physics has yet to be done, even without descending to low-status solid-phase phenomena.
On a completely different note: why does the author think a dark star would necessarily explode before turning into a black hole? A rotating pair of black holes seems like an efficient way to sweep up billions of solar masses of perfectly serviceable mass, and dynamical friction with it seems like a nice way to bleed off momentum.
Very much a valid hypothesis
One RH neutrino must be massless, and another must be 4.8 x 10^8 GeV.
That's incredibly short-sighted. There are many other falsifiable hypotheses and due diligence directs us to make measurements to test those hypotheses.
More generally, it makes zero sense to assume the worst case that cannot be ruled out and use that as an excuse to not pursue science. For example, it is impossible to "falsify" superluminal/nonlocal influence -- and not being able to screen for that renders the whole scientific process fundamentally useless (because there could always be something happening in a neighboring galaxy that is influencing your experiment -- how do you rule that out or control for it?). We simple continue doing science with the optimism that the the universe is not perversely adversarial to our attempts to understand it (and give that optimism fancy names like Occam's razor).
Compared to dark matter detection experiments, an infinitely greater value, as against the conspicuously zero denominator.
My personal educated guess is that the potential value to fundamental physics of identifying dark matter is great enough to justify the cost of trying. You're free to disagree, but you're in no position to say I'm wrong.
While you're at it you'll have to make another argument if you want to persuade me you're in a position to know which are the right questions and which are the wrong ones.
Finally, if the dark energy equation of state can't be measured with experiments, you should've told the Department of Energy. You could've saved them a lot of money.
https://science.osti.gov/hep/Highlights/2019/HEP-2019-08-a
It's not too late to save them even more money, though:
2. If you can't understand whether a room-temperature superconductor would enormously more consequential than ruling out yet another dark-matter candidate, I can only suggest you defer all judgment on matters of value to your wife.
3. You still wholly miss the point, which would be pointless to repeat a fourth time. I recommend you go back and read previous posts in this thread that explain it.
2. If you understand why I personally should value room temperature semiconductors over determining dark ENERGY (not dark matter... that's different) parameters then you should be able to explain your understanding. If you don't explain your understanding, people may suspect you can't explain your understanding perhaps because you don't actually possess understanding.
3. That's so easy to say, even I can say it back to you: you've missed the point, and I recommend you go back and review.
But I'm curious how particle decay would be like for a particle with a de Broglie wavelength of several lightyears, and how would that be affected by the speed of causality.
(EDIT: Or even a few light-minutes (like from Earth to Sun) or whatever distance where we no longer have the luxury of "things looking instantaneous".)
This hunt for it is very parallel to the hunt for the “ether” that Einstein showed didn’t exist. Curiously, the big insight of relativity was getting rid of two bad assumptions: the concept of “simultaneity” and the idea that gravitational acceleration is locally different from other acceleration.
I think the resolution to whatever dark matter is will likely make other fundamental problems in physics simpler as well.
https://www.astronomy.com/science/ask-astro-are-neutrinos-da...
No
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headli...