Has there been any serious discussion about using GitHub for peer reviews? Specifically the pull request functionality?
I’m not sure about the pull request workflow though, how would that work for review? Is your concept more for collaboration?
* It's owned by a (single) commercial corporation, Microsoft.
* There is censorship both by content and in some respects by country of origin.
* The code is closed.
but otherwise it's an interesting idea.
The C++ standardization committee uses GitHub to track papers submitted to them, see: