The answer is much simpler. U.S. cities are too far apart for rail to be practical here.
The Eastern Seaboard is basically perfectly laid out for high-speed rail (Boston - NYC - Philadelphia - Baltimore - DC). The Midwest has tons of ideal city pairs, such as Chicago - Detroit or Chicago - St. Louis. Even a line between Chicago and NYC would be practical (3.5 hours downtown to downtown with modern HSR).
The main problems for HSR in the US are: extremely car-centric development, highly individualistic politics, incapability of pulling off large public projects.