> There is more risk working for a smaller consulting firm
This is the problem. You have consistently said in previous comments that taking higher upfront cash is less risk, and you claimed that's what actors and writers should be doing, instead of asking for residuals. And now you turn around and admit that taking higher upfront cash, which you say you can get from consulting firms, is actually more risky.
So your words seem inconsistent, and somewhat hypocritical, because you're taking the recurring revenue while saying that actors and writers shouldn't.
In any case, it's not clear why you think that working for a BigCo is less risky, because there have been a ton of layoffs lately, so BigCos could fire their employees at any time, and have been doing so. (A lot of them over-hired the past few years.)
> My base pay is far lower than I could get working for another consulting company.
> I’m not baffled residuals exist, I’m baffled that people think that writers and actors “deserve” them instead of it just being a negotiation between cash now and less cash and higher/risk return by accepting them in exchange for less cash up front
> Why should they get residual checks? ... If anything they should negotiate a higher up front payment.
> And that’s something that everyone here fails to understand. For me there are three levels of risk.
> 1. Getting all of my compensation in cash (least downside/least upside)
> The writers are negotiating based on 3. I would be negotiating based on 1.
> I have had the same choices:
> 1. Being risk averse by taking cash up front and choosing to negotiate based on a maximum up front payment