Also, if I believe that newfound productivity is so amazing for stock price, I buy stock. What's wrong with this approach?
Also, if I believe that newfound productivity is so amazing for stock price, I buy stock. What's wrong with this approach?
I suggest that you come and visit Poland and live on the median salary for a year or two.
How about we start building society for the 99.99% of us?
I don’t think owning stock is about disposable income, it’s about saving. I would expect many people have a savings plan, if at least for retirement. So the majority of people directly own stock and there are more who indirectly do through pensions and other instruments that own stock for beneficiary purposes.
[0] https://news.gallup.com/poll/266807/percentage-americans-own...
Purchasing power is also a thing. Median gross salary in Poland is $18000, and about $14000 net. They earn less than 1200 per month, of which 300-400 is spent on rent excluding utilities, add another 50-100 utilities, 200 for food, then gas and transport and you quickly see that the savings are minuscule.
How can you buy stock on 200 (at best) after all expenses?
This is the same way Americans do it.
Purchasing stock hasn’t been difficult for decades and there are many zero fee index funds that you can put small amounts into each month.
I can’t find percent Polish people who own stock but I will bet you $1000 that it’s greater than 0.01%.
I don't get your obsession with Poland. It's a country I have a soft spot for, even though it's not my country of origin, but most importantly my argument is entirely orthogonal to that.
Let's take Cuba, US said don't trade with Cuba if you want to be okay with us, and the world complied. Similarly for all socialist countries, and every country in which the US intervened directly or otherwise.
Countries are not independent islands, and the American government, and the Russian and Chinese regimes sure know how to stick their fingers in every pie available.
The question is: is it better to be a weaker economy in a world where other countries interact with it, or not? If it is, then said economy has to make do with what it has, and while there are geopolitical factors at play, they aren't all bad (indeed if they were even just "more bad than good" then more countries would be like North Korea). Your case of Cuba is a good one: the embargo means that Cuba is more like an independent island, and less like a weaker economy participating in a global economy.
But to relate geopolitics to "society" is still wrong, I think. A society is a smaller thing than "everyone on earth". Inherited familial, political, and institutional norms are roughly at the society level, and they play a large part in how law-abiding, productive and welcoming that society is. A lot of that is bounded at country, although sometimes countries will share cultural lineages that mean they are similar.
P.s. fantastic news on the Polish economy front. Great to hear salaries are on the rise.
They are, but inflation (and shrinkflation) powered by corporate greed has screwed people over the last year; I could fill my tote back with equivalent of 20 euros in September when the local currency was much weaker, whereas now I need to spend more in local currency than I did back then.
Certainly the war has caused inflation, in the sense of "things costing more".
Or that's a myth, everything is setup for them to succeed, and they've captured value that we should all be sharing in because we don't fully account for externalities or the accumulation of capital. As a human being everyone should have a piece of the pie, and we can remove force from the system if we choose to - and we will one day.
There should be a _lot_ more to life than working for other people.
What’s wrong is that you don’t benefit as much as them, and us workers outnumber them. I prioritise the quality of life of a larger quantity of people rather than the capital increase of a select few sociopaths.
I hope those who object who aren't already some degree of socialist will move a little leftwards now.