Imagine facebook decides to subtly change every public post and comment to show some particular person or cause in a better light.
Imagine facebook decides to subtly change every public post and comment to show some particular person or cause in a better light.
We have tons of credible archived sources owned by different institutions. And these sources are successful in large part due to their credibility and trustworthiness.
It's just not economically rational for any of them to start "altering the past", and if they did, they'd be caught basically immediately and their reputation would be ruined.
This isn't an ML/tooling question, it's a question of humans and reputation and economic incentives.
Second, people take screenshots of Facebook posts all the time. They're everywhere. If you suddenly have a ton of people with timestamped screenshots from their phones that show Facebook has changed content, that's exactly the kind of story journalists will pounce on and verify.
The idea that Facebook could or would engage in widespread manipulation of past content and not get caught is just not realistic.
Maybe it is improbable, but there now is the technical possibility which was not there before.
It is valuable to explore that possibility and maybe even work to prevent such a use.
I would be interested in a ledger of cryptographically signed records of important public information such as newspapers, government communication and intellectual discourse.
Your argument that large social media will behave rationally is not backed up by reality. Consider Musk and Twitter.
Detection doesn't really matter, because people are too lazy to validate the facts, and reporters are not interested in reporting them. AI is simply another tool to manipulate people, like Wikipedia, Reddit.com, Twitter, or any other BS psuedo-authority. Think someone will actually crack open a book to prove the AI wrong? Not a chance.
You really think that if the NYT started altering its past stories, other publications would just... ignore it?
It would be a front-page scandal that the WaPo would be delighted to report on. As well as a hundred other news publications.
Thankfully.
If you can't alter world news headlines, you can still alter the tone of the article. If you can't alter front page news, you still can alter the remaining 95% of news.
Influencing public opinion is more subtle than the one important headline per day.
You are also ignoring the fact that news sites regularly edit published articles already, from fixed typos to corrections to large re-editings.
This isn't about a small percentage of stories, it's not about tone, it's the fact that if the NYT ever did this even once with the intention to truly "alter the past" it would be a major scandal.
And obviously things like corrections or taking down libelous content aren't included.
So no, I'm not constructing any kind of straw man here. I'm saying that the threat of subtly nefariously "altering the past" isn't realistic because it would be caught and exposed and there's no financial motivation to do it in the first place.
This is already happening without generative AI, and this new stuff is only going to speed things up exponentially.