Science Corrects Itself, Right? A Scandal at Stanford Says It Doesn’t
scientificamerican.com
scientificamerican.com
I don't get it. They're just declaring that there should be 5000 retractions, and because only a tiny fraction of that actually ends up being retracted, that science doesn't correct itself? Where did this number come from? Is it just a list of studies with sus numbers? I feel like the authors (founders of retraction watch) is doing a massive disservice to their cause by casually skipping over this.
There are informational internet hyperlinks you can follow, and a list of references.
[0]Excellant discussion here: https://martinsweatman.blogspot.com/2023/07/the-scientific-m...
Aristotle's ideas ruled the roost for millenia, before they were closely inspected. Just the other day I listened to someone complaining that mis-translations of his ideas resulted in some of the big blunders attributed to him (e.g. 'heavier things fall faster).
The datapoint about so many retractions is a red herring. I think they don't expect people to click through the link and observe the graph that shows that, while rising, the current rate of retraction's still below 8% (I think they mean 8%. These guys label their y-axis with '%' but then use fractions of 1 instead of values out of 100. Gross.)
For a purely human-driven global pursuit, I'd say 8% error rate is well within acceptable margins. Seems like it's functioning as intended? Every aspect of society has to deal with inept spam nowadays, so it isn't like the issue being discussed is scoped specifically to science, either. Charlatans gonna charlatan.
Ah yes, because the only people doing science are liberals. There are no other people with any other political philosophies in modern science, so clearly your root-cause analysis is sound.