If you only get one public ipv4 assigned by your ISP, there is simply no way to set it up in a way that every device on your network is reachable from the internet on all ports with just one click.
If you only get one public ipv4 assigned by your ISP, there is simply no way to set it up in a way that every device on your network is reachable from the internet on all ports with just one click.
NAT (particularly NAPT) actually has the potential to lower overall
security because it creates the illusion of a security barrier, but
does so without the managed intent of a firewall. Appropriate
security mechanisms are implemented in the end host, without reliance
on assumptions about routing hacks, firewall filters, or missing NAT
translations, which may change over time to enable a service to a
neighboring host. In general, defined security barriers assume that
any threats are external, leading to practices that make internal
breaches much easier.
* https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc2993#section-9The more likely scenario is your system (or phone) gets compromised, it lives behind the supposedly secure NAT "firewall", and since you had a false sense of security from NAT your entire internal network has all sorts of holes.
The era of network moats was over long ago, and NAT is simply perpetuating the illusion.
I'd rather take the risk of SPI IPv6 firewalls, have the alleged chaos of allegedly exposed IoT systems, and force everyone to up their security game: short-term pain is healthier IMHO.
It's far easier than that - web pages running on your machine are also "calling from inside the house" if you will (https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/campfire.png)
You load up some js on any random site and it can do a pretty thorough scan of your network in a few minutes.
But not on your own network or your parents/friends whoever. You want others to have that pain, as a policy decision, right? It's reasonable but worth clarifying.
Most home networks have no management, or intent, at all. People just buy whatever boxes are sold to them and plug them in.
Now, yes, if you actually design a network, and properly set things up, then a firewall will give you better control. Will grampa Jim do that? Absolutely not.