I feel like you are reading a lot into the grandparent comment. Seemed like a pretty innocuous question. Innocent until proven guilty and all that.
The Jewish people have a right to exist.
I'm not going to stand blithely by while people chip away at that by JAQing the proposition that there is even such a thing as the Jewish people.
The question is is whether it's a useful category for this purpose. I think it is.
But you can also divide it up various ways - Levantine, Sephardic, Ashkenazi.... Are the Lemba Jewish according to you?
Does it matter whether they're observant or not?