The observation that "we only have N years of data so we don't know anything!" creeps up frequently in climate denial arguments.
But I am sincerely curious, do you earnestly believe that, ignoring the other methods of estimating these values we have, that if we had satellite measurements going back 100s of years they would reveal that this level of heating is in fact quite common?
Of course we do have data that suggests, at least as far back as 1880 [0] that we are in an era of record sea surface temperatures [0]. But even if we didn't, we have countless other observations that strongly suggest the planet is heating up in multiple ways. We also have a fairly good hypothesis as well that nicely explains all of these observations (CO2 released by human industrialization is capturing more solar heat, causing the planet to warm). Yes, when we try to get too granular with our predictions the models aren't as great, but overall we have a nice hypothesis that seems to explain a wide range of observed phenomena over a large range of time scales for different data sets.
When you take into account all of this information, while it is important to always remain open to skepticism, it seems remarkably unlikely that what we're observing is in fact common in recent human history and therefore not particularly worth of note.
0. https://www.epa.gov/climate-indicators/climate-change-indica...
> In 2007 the world consumed roughly 500 quadrillion BTUs of energy and is expected to increase at 1.4% per year. [1] About 90% of this energy was generated through fossil fuel combustion with a typical efficiency of 30-40%. The remaining 60-70% of the energy was lost to the environment via automotive exhaust, industrial processes, and more.
On another note, this would also imply that if all of the excess energy stored in the ocean (20e22J, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ocean_heat_content#/media/File...) would be dumped into the atmosphere at once, it would warm up by 33°C
No. Where would you get that idea? I don’t doubt the sea is warming, there is data for that. I don’t doubt the sea has been warming rapidly since 1880 (or their abouts). We have data for that. I don't doubt that 2000 years ago the earth was a lot warmer than it is today. We have data for that, and not just all the “Viking village emerges from melting ice” stories.
What I lament is journalists inability to give the proper context.
No, 2000 years ago, or during the “medieval warm period” much later than that that people making your style of argument usually point to (and better fits the Viking villages comment), global temperatures were signifantly cooler than today (warmer than the end of the Little Ice Age in the mid-1800s, sure, but cooler than today.) We have the data for that.
Not sure this helps your argument.
https://thehill.com/policy/energy-environment/4086841-were-e...
First of all, it makes your overall argument much weaker than you think it does. If you had just stated something along the lines of "Note this data only begins in the 1980s", which the graph also clearly states, I would have considered it a fair observation. I would still agree with the general conclusion, primarily because there are so many other data points this year, that we are "generally fucked". And my "generally fucked" I don't mean that Earth will become uninhabitable, but certainly many regions will be. Count me as one of the "climate change immigrants" - I'm started the process of moving out of my Southwestern US city because (in a reverse analogy), this is just the tip of the iceberg, and this summer has been brutal, and I'm generally used to brutal summers.
There is good data going back to 1880 on ocean tempreture that shows a consistent climbing trend.