After being on this connection for ~2 years, I cannot imagine going back to Comcast. I've actually been looking at moving, and my #1 filter is fiber network availability. I will literally skip an otherwise perfect property if it doesn't have access, or the ability to add access for <6 figures.
We're in the same boat - we won't buy a house if AT&T Fiber (or at least Sonic Fiber) isn't available at the address. Showing that only Xfinity is available is a legit dealbreaker for us. Xfinity has frequent outages here in Sacramento.
I used to support municipal fiber in my home town (Seattle) -- but after many years of dollars spent and zero progress, the city finally mothballed the effort.
And now I have fiber to the home (Centurylink) at a price so low I don't even think about it.
I think the key is competition. If your city doesn't have competition, it absolutely makes sense to create competition from the municipality.
Fiber is simply in a completely different universe of quality compared to DOCSIS & DSL.
AT&T is literally the worst thing on earth... unless you have access to their fiber offerings. Then it might be among the best. I can get 5gbps in my area now but I don't bother. Internet is solved for me as far as I am concerned now.
If I had any other option, even one with worse service, I'd switch away in a heartbeat if the new company were easier to deal with.
But the satisfaction is because it’s symmetric fiber. I’m sure CenturyLink DSL is garbage, just like Comcast coaxial.
Our municipal ISP failed and was sold to a private company.