There's always the form vs function debate but it's a shame that more doesn't manage to have both form and function if the respective specialists could coordinate
Yeah, no. I don't think you use macOS/win at all if you say stuff like that. It feels and always has felt rough around the edges.
I genuinely like and dislike most OS UIs I've tried. They all have things that irk me. While windows settings has gotten more consistent, it's also all the more painful when you had gotten used to the "old way" of doing things and where to look. If MS executives could just get TF out of their own way on some of the stupidity and force-feeding.
Mac, just feels a bit dated at this point, but the touchpad integration across all apps is great. Not to mention the macbook touchpads being second to none in terms of usability.
Linux, I can shift to almost exactly what I want. There are rough edges and spots you cannot reach via UI, but it mostly works without issue. Been using Budgie as my DE for over a year, fairly customized and like it a lot.
https://i.stack.imgur.com/JDDku.png
To my knowledge, modern GNOME does not have this which is sad. There's this webpage instead:
https://help.gnome.org/users/gnome-help/stable/shell-keyboar...
"Half-maximizing" windows with Super+Left and Super+Right is very handy when I need to see things side-by-side.
Moving windows from one screen to another by pressing Super and doing drag-and-drop, and moving windows across workspaces with Shift+Super+PgUp and Shift+Super+PgDown are also convenient.
In my opinion GNOME and GTK apps generally get those details more "correct", though GNOME 3 and up goes way overboard on padding. Strip that padding down with a theme and its design is solid though, and Cinnamon, XFCE, and MATE get these right out of the box with no modifications necessary.