Would those civilians have died anyhow had the germans had the military materiel to hold each city longer, which would have required fighting block by block - Imagine the Battle of Berlin but on a continental scale.
Would those civilians have died anyhow had the germans had the military materiel to hold each city longer, which would have required fighting block by block - Imagine the Battle of Berlin but on a continental scale.
Probably just as long. The reason the American forces had such an easy time advancing into France once they had landed is because most of the German forces were on the Eastern front, where the USSR had to do the extremely bloody fighting all the way to Berlin anyway.
Had the Germany retained said industrial capacity, wouldn't the USSR have to fight even bloodier fighting for longer? How do we know whether they would prevail or loose eventually in this alternative history scenario?
Could you elaborate on how you logically arrive at such a conclusion?
The bombings did little to disrupt said industry. Though there were deaths and damage, it was repaired and the machines kept working. Actual severe disruptions to the German war economy occurred when they lost access to raw materials, such as the Romanian oil fields. There are studies to this effect, but it is more obviously visible by how the German armies kept shooting until they were eliminated by other shooting armies.
Strategic bombing also failed to eliminate the Chinese/North Koreans, the Vietcong, the Taliban...
What makes you think they wouldn't have been able to continue shooting for much longer?
> eliminate the Chinese/North Koreans
Wasn't North Korea pretty much entirely defeated by the time China interfered (and Chinese territory wasn't bombed)?
> Vietnam
The strategic bombing campaign in North Vietnam wasn't that successful and also quite costly and US couldn't follow it up with a ground invasion.
So if that equipment was to be sent to Russia investing those resources into (supposedly) less effective bombers might have been the more pragmatic long-term option (at the horrible cost of additional Russian lives).
It's not that obvious to me. Of course they kept shooting. It's hard to imagine a scale of destruction necessary to bring an industralized country's economy to a full halt.
Still, deaths mean decreased workforce which is already strained by the military draft.
While, of course, they repaired what they could, (re)building a factory to its full potential takes years and substansial workforce.
As to Vietnam/Afganistan, withholding moral judgment on their invasion in the first place, from what very little I know about these historical events, the US operations accomplished their military goals there. They later withdrew not due to Vietcong/Taliban's efforts, but as a result of internal political/societal processes in the US itself.
This imagines a strain on the workforce that never really existed. Industrial countries can and have staffed factories and repair crews with women and the infirm.
>As to Vietnam/Afganistan, withholding moral judgment on their invasion in the first place, from what very little I know about these historical events, the US operations accomplished their military goals there.
Part of their military goals were destruction of the enemy force via sustained bombing campaigns. These goals were never achieved and instead abandoned.
Point taken. Thank you for engaging in the conversation.
> The idea that universally useful conclusions can be drawn is what is incorrect.
You're bringing up an interesting point. I'd like to deeply learn history someday, when I retire, maybe...
nobody knows when a war will end. You're making the argument that attrition works
They did not.
> They later withdrew not due to Vietcong/Taliban’s efforts, but as a result of internal political/societal processes in the US itself.
They withdrew because they failed to achieve their military objectives, and the support for continuing to bear the cost of the war without having done so and without confidence that would change in the near future eroded.
If they had achieved their military objective, then they would have left sooner (or transitioned to a non-combat footing), having won the war.
How did you come to this conclusion?
I don't know whether it could be justified or not but I don't see how one can just outright say the strategic bombing did not significantly damage German infrastructure, manufacturing capacity, morale and also require Germany to invest a lot of resources and manpower into their airforce and ground defenses.
1) It rallied civilian morale to side with the government. People were aggrieved that they were being bombed, and it stiffened their resistance and motivated them to work harder towards the war effort.
2) Despite strategic bombing targeting factories and industrial infrastructure, they only caused superficial damage. The damaged factories were quickly brought back online, and the newly motivated workers significantly increased their output. In some books they cited increases of output in bombed German factories of above 100% towards the end of the war.
3) Strategic bombers are extremely costly to produce and operate. Casualties on strategic bombing missions in the beginning were incredibly high, with some air wings suffering ~50% personnel loss during an air campaign. All of this loss resulted in no changed on the battlefield, and negligible or even counter-productive effects on enemy industrial production.
In summary, strategic bombing of civilian targets and cities was a colossal waste of time, resources, and manpower. All of those things could have been redirected elsewhere to help end the war earlier.
https://malwarwickonbooks.com/strategic-bombing-in-wwii/
---
While we're on the topic, one place where strategic bombing was successful is targeting Romanian and German oil refineries. The loss in German oil production directly lead to the war ending earlier, and the hamstringing of German logistics and consequently military operations.
https://www.maxwell.af.mil/News/Display/Article/1887774/wwii...
As Rommel would say: amateurs talk strategy, professionals talk logistics.
This experience makes me think that even though strategic bombing was wasteful in WW2, it still has a place in modern military doctrine. A large strategic bombing fleet can act as a deterrent, and a way to quickly subdue less sophisticated opponents by bombing all their critical infrastructure back into the stone age.
It should also be noted however that large scale American strategic bombing during the Vietnam conflict was largely unsuccessful.
The final assault on Berlin cost 80,000 Russian lives and 100,000 German.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Berlin
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_casualties#:~:t....