And really, what else could goog/fb etc do -- what other company or person for that matter would pay someone in order to provide them a service? Governments tax things they want less of (e.g. smoking) so this should be no surprise.
And really, what else could goog/fb etc do -- what other company or person for that matter would pay someone in order to provide them a service? Governments tax things they want less of (e.g. smoking) so this should be no surprise.
Sylvain Poisson of Hebdos Quebec confidently said “they made those threats in Australia and elsewhere and every time they back down.” Chris Pedigo of the U.S.-based Digital Context Next assured the committee “it’s important to understand what happens when these bills become law. In Australia, they moved quickly to secure deals.
And apparently we've yet to hear from Google on this regarding Canada. But what's different? It's hard to see how Google can have a principled objection to Canadian but not Australian danegeld.Basically it appears that the tech companies signing the same kinds of deals as elsewhere is being spun as a success of the legislation, even though the law does not apply to anyone, as a face saving measure.
1. Whether a significant bargaining power imbalance exists.
2. Whether the platform has made a significant contribution to the sustainability of news media.
As to 1. the mere existence of the code seems to redress any power imbalance somewhat. As for 2. The actual deals Facebook and Google made in response to the law being enacted are confidential, but many news media companies said they were happy with the results so there wouldn't seem to be any reason to designate these organisations in the first place.
We were advised by Australia's top policy wonk, but maybe he was in earnest and didn't understand the game he was in.
Your policymakers are either
- earnest and incredibly stupid
- malicious and only somewhat stupid
There's just no in-between here. A child that has done ten minutes of research on the issue could realize the problems with these bills.
Now, whether posting links is the kind of enrichment that deserves payment is a separate question. But the idea that Facebook is somehow providing news sites a service in some sort of charitable way by allowing URLs to be posted by 3rd parties is ridiculous.
The equation is different for Google and search indexing, though. And of course once Google started harvesting content directly from third party websites and shoving it into answerboxes, actively siphoning traffic away, it got more complex.
In most cases, yes:
>Our users – and in this case news publishers – choose to share it themselves. Globally, more than 90% of organic views on article links from news publishers are on links posted by the publishers themselves.
https://about.fb.com/news/2023/05/metas-position-on-canadas-...
Not necessarily. Meta eliminating news from Facebook and Instagram is consistent with either of two scenarios:
1. They're playing 'hardball' to negotiate a better outcome
2. The amount they would have to pay outweighs any benefit they gain from keeping news links on Facebook and Instagram.
If a prospective employee would not provide a business with more than minimum wage in productivity, it is not a 'negotiating struggle' if they don't hire him; it simply means it isn't worth it to them.
The difference here being, if this is simply a negotiating tactic, it is rational to just outwait Meta; they will restore news links eventually, because the benefit outweighs the cost.
But if it isn't worth it because of scenario 2, they could just never restore news links.
So the real question here is: How much value is added to Facebook and Instagram by allowing news links on those platforms?
Personally, I wouldn't be surprised if the value added were negative.