VSC is a very good tool. And if someone needs to be productive right away, it's easy to get him going. Vim has a steeper learning curve, but it is easy to make it your own, perfectly suited to you and your projects. As you said, it's not one or another. I use VSC now and then, but going back to my Vim setup is always a delight.
The arguments about the home row are valid. With VIM, text on the screen become an extension of your thinking. And your finger and the keyboard are just the medium that connects both. How I do an action is how I think about doing it. Moving around and editing text has the same cognitive load as entering new text. The things that require me to go away from the home row are unusual operations that also require my full focus and attention.