That's the last thing I want. Random WIP commits being sent off to some central hub? Fuck that, man. Fuck that.
>And for commits to be locked and stable once made. Git’s ability to re-write history is, imho, a huge mistake and I don’t think actually necessary to support Linux. Flattening on PR merge doesn’t require a rewrite.
Being able to re-write history is absolutely necessary. I seriously doubt you've ever looked at a patch series posted for any free software project if you say that rewriting history isn't necessary.
To put it quite simply: my data is under my control. I can do whatever I want with it. I commit frequently because it is useful to be able to go back in history through changes as I make them. For the purpose of publication, it is not useful to see the various stages I went through when thinking about how to solve a problem. That's not what git history is for. It's for presenting a logical series of changes in a way that is easy to understand and bisect. Flattening on 'PR merge' is abysmal. I don't want one massive commit. I want a series of logical commits.