The question is where is the paying audience ? The answer to that is a bit less clear.
Also, given how many musicians and music fans appear to NOT know about Bandcamp, it's tricky to gauge the extent to which that model is an alternative or not.
The question is where is the paying audience ? The answer to that is a bit less clear.
Also, given how many musicians and music fans appear to NOT know about Bandcamp, it's tricky to gauge the extent to which that model is an alternative or not.
My point is this: most people who want to be musicians will NEVER make a living from sales of anything related to their music. Not from streaming. Not from touring. Not from merchandise.
So why settle for an absolute pittance from streaming sales, when you could instead adopt a strategy that accepts the (likely) limits of your success, but maybe gets you a couple of hundred dollars a month extra, at least some of the time ?
Success would be nice, but if, instead, people have heard my music and appreciate it? Listen to it over and over again? I'd take that over beer money. Beer money would be nice though.
So, if I understand correctly, your point is that people shouldn't try to make a living off music, period. That's fine, but art has always been a difficult road for a career; the advent of streaming has little to do with this.
> So why settle for an absolute pittance from streaming sales, when you could instead adopt a strategy that accepts the (likely) limits of your success, but maybe gets you a couple of hundred dollars a month extra, at least some of the time ?
That's not unlike asking, "Why start a business when you could instead work a 9-5 and probably make more money?"
Oh, in the realm of recorded music, it absolutely has a LOT to do with it.
From the early 1950s until the advent of streaming, record labels played an important role as cross-subsidy systems. You might not like Brittney Spears, but the cut of her album sales that went to her record company allowed her label to continue to work with many artists who were barely profitable (if at all).
Streaming (and to a lesser extent, megastars forming their own vertically integrated corporations) has ended that model entirely. If you make "niche genre" music, you're going to be operating without any potential cross-subsidy from more popular music, which translates to either working without a record label at all, or working with a "niche genre" label that helps with marketing but also has extremely low cash flow.
> That's not unlike asking, "Why start a business when you could instead work a 9-5 and probably make more money?"
I see it as a very different question. I'm acknowledging the appeal of pursuing your artistic inclinations, and I think we should encourage as many folks as possible to do that. But I'm also saying "if you think you're going to make a living from this, you're almost certainly mistaken". There are plenty of things people keep doing in their lives without the prospect of making money from it. I'm suggesting that it would be better if more people understood that in 2023, music probably ought to be one of those things, rather than the basis of a dream way of making a living.
It's more like "should you start a business based on your hobby, that almost certainly will not make enough to live on and stands a good chance of destroying your interest in the hobby, or should you accept that it's a side-gig that bring s you joy and occasionally a little bit of extra income?"
Alas its not really possible to make a living from music. Sure some rounding error of people can, working terrible hours, always on the road, grinding away. It's a pretty bad lifestyle for pretty bad money.
Yes there are successes, but the fact you can -name them- is a bad bad sign for an industry.
If you like to play music, then do it got fun, not money. If you accumulate enough for a meal out, then great. Get a job, pay the bills, and enjoy making the music, even if no-one listens.
Stream if you like, sell albums if you like, either way it's gonna be a pittence. Arguing over which is better is meaningless in the sense that they're both bad. Focus on the fun. Don't let the money rob you of the joy.
Oh, and starting a record label? Good luck with that... but it's a daft idea.
Really?
I used to play in genre bands 20 years ago. No one made a living doing it. There are a lot of rose colored glasses being worn here.
The reason musicians made money in the past is because there were so few of them. The barrier to entry - buying synths and studio time, distributing music, whatever - was so high that only a fraction of the people who wanted to make music, could afford make music. A lot of us just dreamed about having the money to even get started.
The result was that the demand for music far outstripped the supply of people who had the means to produce it. Which is profoundly unfair.
Now everyone can make great sounding music and distribute it globally for free. The result is a gazillion genre musicians.
Sure, none of them can make a living selling songs (how quaint) but in the past they would have been completely denied the opportunity to make music at all, even for themselves.
The current situation is much, much better: everyone has the opportunity to make music, and listeners have more music available than they could have ever imagined, and it's all essentially free.
Entirely agreed, and a point I often find myself making in conversations about this stuff.
However:
> I used to play in genre bands 20 years ago. No one made a living doing it. There are a lot of rose colored glasses being worn here.
I've never been a fan of spectacularly popular music. I used to have a collection of about 3000 vinyl albums, and of that, about 2/3 were by musicians I would characterize as "genre". Of that, I would guesstimate at least half of them used to make some sort of living from their recorded music (based on a quick mental survey of the musicians and what I knew/know about their lives).
This is (was) particularly true of jazz, improvised music, electronic music.
> The current situation is much, much better: everyone has the opportunity to make music, and listeners have more music available than they could have ever imagined, and it's all essentially free.
I mostly agree with this, with the proviso that I'm not sure we really understand what the long term impact will be of "even less people than before can making a living from selling recordings of their music".
I’d be surprised if the absolute number is lower. Sure, the percentage is way lower but that’s because more people are making music.
But like, are there more say, punk rock bands making a living with their music today than there were 20 years ago? Probably.
Also, notice that the usual line about "it's the merch, touring, etc that really makes money" is only true because of streaming. It's precisely because you make essentially nothing from "the music" anymore that the revenue stream from other things now matters more than ever. But with systems like Bandcamp, where the artist is collecting 85% of the gross per digital album download (which could be on the order of $4.50-$11.00 per sale) the balance between these things can shift quite a bit.
Of course, if you've got dedicated merch buyers, cooking up new merch is generally easier and faster than another album (though for some, maybe not).
Given that "bands make all their money from merch and touring" has been true since at least 1970, I don't think you can blame it on streaming, no.
Before Spotify was paying out fractions of a penny per stream, you just had record labels taking $11.99 out of every $12 CD sale instead.
But you're right that label robbery of artists played a big role in the significance of merchandise. It just wasn't true to the same extent in (say) the 70s, because revenue from actual music sales was larger. That was particularly true for musicians who had significant merch sales - they also had really significant music sales revenue.
As I noted elsewhere here, the one upside of label thievery was their ability to cross-subsidize artists. Even tiny (in terms of general sales) labels like ECM got a huge hit every once in a while (e.g. Jarrett's Koeln Concert) that enabled them to keep working with artists whose albums barely broke even. That model has essentially ended now.