California Tested Different Minimum Speed Limits for Lanes. It Didn’t Work
thedrive.com
thedrive.com
US highways (and driving in general) will always be fucked as long as the only requirement for a driver's license is a pulse, and you never get ticketed for ignoring the rules of the road. Your average American driver is lazy, stupid, combative, uneducated, clumsy, or some combination of them, and they will never be inconvenienced by the behavior enough to change it.
The only way to fix this is to enforce the rules that already exist, which will never be done.
> Except when overtaking and passing on the right is permitted, the driver of an overtaken vehicle, on audible signal, shall give way to the right in favor of the overtaking vehicle.
https://casetext.com/statute/code-of-maryland/article-transp...
One interesting difference between the german autobahn and american freeways seems to be how the left lane is treated.
On the autobahn, if someone is going faster in the left lane, the slower person should pull right.
In the US, if the person in the left lane is going the speed limit or over, they don't feel any need to move to the right for someone going faster.
Lazy careless drivers leave the right lane underutilized, congregating on the left side because they can't be bothered with monitoring let alone handling potentially merging traffic.
So the right lane often becomes the only way to get around these clumped up clusterfucks, and to minimize time spent in the right lane while overtaking, it often occurs at quite extralegal speeds.
A special situation is the 2-lane part of highway 5 between SF and LA. Sometimes one truck needs to pass another, causing traffic in the left lane during the pass. Courteous drivers basically form a line in the left lane waiting for this. A few people pass this entire line on the right then cut in.
The existence of the Lexus Lane makes that more important where it's in effect because the "left lane" for most cars is closer to the right lane.
Drive in the furthest lane to the right that is practical. Merge left to pass a person in front of you. Merge back right when you are no longer passing. Do this regardless of which lane you are in.
This truck behavior is a recent change, the last ten years at most. I have certainly noticed that when merging I essentially never have to speed up or slow down for a big rig. It's certainly easier to merge with a light truck or car!
But the organization of traffic has almost completely broken down in the San Francisco Area. I have heard that the California Highway Patrol more or less refuses to enforce any traffic regulation that isn't driven by safety. And to be fair, I rarely see CHP cars, so they may well be spread so thin that they can barely keep the flow of traffic from going 20+ MPH over the limit.
Ok, but what about the other five lanes? Only use the left lane for passing works when traffic is light. When traffic gets heavier, you need to use all lanes to increase throughput; even though it makes passing more difficult.
2) Always pass on the left.
Breaking either rule is a > $1000 fine, and points on your license.
This is how it works everywhere I’ve driven except California, and it works great.
During congestion, there is invariably a car in the fast lane with no cars in front of it, and a line of 1000 cars behind it. That driver should lose their license.
> On a highway with unobstructed pavement not occupied by parked vehicles and wide enough for two or more lines of vehicles moving lawfully in the same direction as the overtaking vehicle;
Otherwise known as what everyone calls a highway. All the rules about keeping to the right to allow passing do not apply when passing on the right is allowed.
Of course, someone who is licensed to drive in MD is allowed to drive in all 50 states, even without being trained on their laws.
https://casetext.com/statute/code-of-maryland/article-transp...
In fact, if neither of those conditions apply, that alone is a pretty good sign that there's not particularly significant congestion.
Every BMW, Audi, and Mercedes that I've driven has had cup holders. This seems like one of those tropes like "Russian cosmonauts just used pencils!" that is easily debunked with even the most rudimentary of searches, but somehow lives on in the zeitgeist.
Enforcement is the only way laws have any effect at all, otherwise they are words on paper nobody reads.
FTFY
Within indexical semiosis: The left lane = the fast lane
Ergo driver can identify as driving fast without regard to the actual speed limit or whether or not they are passing other vehicles. Ask people within FL what the left lane of the highway is called and you will seldom hear “the passing lane.”
Fascinating. I wonder why. Perhaps people are generally so confident that they are driving at the right speed, not cluttering the traffic (even when others do think so), they don't consider it a necessity to move over the slower lanes (even when they should). A sign of minimum speed, instead of being a reminder, on the one hand confuses some into thinking it's the maximum speed, and on the other hand, challenges that confidence---surely I'm not so incapable a driver that I can't maintain 60+ mph!
> The police found the minimum speeds to be essentially unenforceable, observing that drivers were passing more on the right, a quarter of all motorists didn't even notice the signs, and 13% of citations issued for minimum speed violations indicated that drivers confused “minimum” for “maximum.”
Striking, IMO, that their conclusion was "unenforceable". That might be the main take here: California highway patrol obsesses on some rules and just plain doesn't bother with others. So in practice there is no risk to grabbing a lane - any lane - and acting as if you own it.
Sadly, the test is no good in an environment where most drivers are very undisciplined and also confused about the tests (e.g., mistaking "minimum" for "maximum"), and there is insufficient time for retraining and habituation.
I'm sure it could work, but it probably requires a far more educated and disciplined approach to driving.