From the discussion it seems like the article may be interesting but based off of the definition of tragedy of the commons it seems like madness lies ahead. If the tragedy of the commons definition is indicative of what is to come reading the rest does not seem like a good choice for leisure reading.
I genuinely am interested in knowing if the definition of tragedy of the commons is indicative of the rest of the work? (Sorry the edit button is gone from my original post)
There was a great article recently on being a good reader. I can't seem to find it again, but the general point was that you have to assume some level of good faith and try to see through inevitably fuzzy wording to assess the fundamental points that constitute real value and insight. In reading, you win if you learn something, not if you defeat an argument.
(Or maybe there's a broader problem if an article making the front page of HN doesn't count as sufficient endorsement in itself...?)