Paul Allen did this in 1974 without the Internet or modern software tools.
I think it is absolutely extraordinary and incredibly impressive.
Paul Allen did this in 1974 without the Internet or modern software tools.
I think it is absolutely extraordinary and incredibly impressive.
Compared to modern programming, assembler on a 16- or 36-bit machine is simple, logical, and not at all abstract. DEC made a point of offering high quality detailed docs to students, and there was a kind of assembler culture that produced operating systems like TOPS-10, compilers for various languages, and editing tools, often with access to the sources.
And as others have pointed out, the 8080 was not a complex processor. So mapping its instructions to macros wasn't hugely challenging.
I had a friend who wrote a Z80 emulator - a harder challenge - on a PDP-10 as a spare time hobby project. It took about a month of after-hours programming. Full-time, it would have taken much less.
More interesting is that it's possible Gates & Allen had access to the sources for the PDP-11 4K word Dartmouth BASIC.
I have no idea if the original 8-bit MS-BASIC was a clean room reimplementation. But it's at least possible it wasn't.
^^^ This.
Back in the 80s I wrote a 8051 assembler running on a Z80 system. This involves a parser, and also a bunch of tables with opcodes, operand formats & so on.
Took a number of weeks parttime (not sure if I ever completed it, but the bulk of the functionality was there iirc). This was using just text editor, Z80 assembler, maybe a debugger, and 8051 family datasheet(s).
Apart from emulating I/O (as simple or complex as that in emulated machine), difficulty-wise this should be similar to writing an emulator.
8051 and 8080 are not very different in complexity.
Anyone doing anything with computers in 1974 did it without the internet or modern software tools. It seems to me it was an era where you were either a 'computer whizz' or else you didn't really get involved with computers.
Not saying its not impressive though, I think any programmers from that period who are still remembered now would be rated as 'very very good' by modern standards.
I'd highly encourage anyone to read a data sheet for something like an ESP32.
I once stuffed a software UART, simple command interpreter and a temperature control algorithm into a microcontroller that had a single accumulator and a grand total of 504 bytes of OTP Flash (a donut to anyone who can guess what it was from that odd memory size :-) and didn't give it a second thought until years later someone pointed out that it was unusual.
It's literally not extraordinary because it wasn't that rare of a thing to do. I'd expect most expert engineers of the day would be able to accomplish the same.
The internet and modern tools are merely conveniences that increase productivity. Devs have been working without them for longer than they've been working with them.