But sure, only compatible cultures should talk to one another?
So which cultures pair well with yours and which don’t, then? Who would you kick off the Internet/social media?
No, this would be taking my argument too far. Online communities develop their own cultures and norms, mostly borrowed from the real-world cultural contexts of their constituent members. Someone trying to participate in a community without conforming to those cultural expectations is going to cause trouble.
> So which cultures pair well with yours and which don’t, then? Who would you kick off the Internet/social media?
I see no reason to kick anyone off social media, but I think unfocused social media platforms like Facebook, Twitter/X, Instagram, TikTok, &c. are causing social problems. There were Americans in America protesting against coronavirus lockdowns in Australia, and there are Australians who have reoriented their entire identities around Donald Trump and QAnon: people are being radicalised about events that have nothing to do with them, and over which they have no control.
The social media I want to see is the old-style message fora that existed before modern social media: phpBB- and vBulletin-based communities that were designed around shared interests, not platform functionality.
Moderation is a real problem for modern social platforms. In the 90s, we had the so-called Scunthorpe Problem: AOL users living in UK towns like Scunthorpe and Penistone were banned from the AOL support forum for giving honest answers to inquiries into their location. The problem persists in a more subtle form, even on this website, in the Forbidden Meatball Problem[0].
Interest-based online communities would be able to carry out their own moderation according to their own cultures, and consequently avoid these problems.
[0] https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/british-dish-encounters-q...
What is the action you're suggesting?