Radio operator exposure to RF/microwave radiation and the risk of brain tumors (2006)
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
> No significant association between occupational exposure to RF/MW-EMF and brain tumors was found.
> For glioma, the adjusted odds ratio for highly exposed persons compared with persons not highly exposed was 1.21 (95% confidence interval: 0.69, 2.13); for meningioma, it was 1.34 (95% confidence interval: 0.64, 2.81).
They found a very small dose-response relationship for gliomas and meningiomas and think it merits further investigation.
> However, the slight increase in risk observed with increasing duration of exposure merits further research with larger sample sizes.
This continues to feel like aspartame.
They are saying "We have no idea what the odds are, radio could LOWER your odds down to 69% or raise them up to 213%." Scientists treat this as a non-result, try the study again with more data.
A confidence interval that IS statistically significant will have an upper-bound below one, or a lower bound above one i.e. (95% confidence interval 1.10, 3.31) meaning we can be 95% sure that this increases your odds by 10% or more [up to 331%]
Rosin has a complex molecular structure that is too big to cross the blood-brain barrier.
It is a lung irritant and has an associated lung disease risk of the form of adult-onset asthma but it cannot cause brain cancer; there is no known link between rosin and any form lung cancer.
Most of us don't use rosin anymore, as it's an absolutely awful flux, synthetic fluxes are more effective and don't have the same risks - although it's probably too early to say on carcinogenic risks, but needless to say with many of us gen Xers having spent our lives using synthetic flux, we'd have expected to see cancer clusters by now.
You will definitely be getting lead dust on your hands when working with lead solder though. Hopefully most people are smart enough to wash their hands after soldering, regardless of lead content, but I wouldn't be surprised if a lot of hobbyists were eating lead without noticing.
I would more naturally link rosin to respiratory system cancers, for example.
Soldering hazards, especially if we're speaking about cancers, is mainly related to rosin yes.
Now you're willing to switch the discussion to IQ drop? From cancer?
Lead on the other hand vaporizes well above soldering temperatures... Can / does rosin vapor can carry lead?
Or is it more complex than that? Because I've always thought microwave radiation is safe since it's non-ionizing.
So the question with regard to tumors is can this heating cause changes in DNA? My non-scientific/non-medical opinion is that it can but not before major structural damage occurs killing the cell anyways. Even if the cell survives the DNA damage is likely to be widespread, not just a few base pairs, and the cell would destroy itself.
In my opinion this kind of study continues to try and prove a negative, which is very difficult.
But UV is ionizing. The article you linked to says:
> UV-B and UV-A rays are two forms of high-energy radiation that ionize (i.e., remove electrons from) molecules in a photochemical reaction that generates new molecular products.
UV-A and UV-B are non-ionizing. UV-C is ionizing but it's blocked by the ozone layer almost completely. So when we talk about UV radiation we generally mean A and B, and it is non-ionizing.
UV-A and especially UV-B are still capable of inducing DNA damage despite being non-ionizing. Specific mechanisms here. [1].
I didn't catch that in my initial article, but it is wrong on that particular point.
From [1]:
> UV-A and visible light energy (up to 670–700 nm) are able to generate singlet oxygen (1O2) that can damage DNA via indirect photosensitizing reactions.
> UV-B radiation is one of the most important energetic solar components that may lead to the formation of three major classes of DNA lesions, such as cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPDs), pyrimidine 6-4 pyrimidone photoproducts (6-4PPs), and their Dewar isomers.
Anyways, it's an interesting paper.
I wasn't aware of this, so I looked it up. It seems some UV light can be ionizing, such as the shorter wavelength variety. UVB is not, but can cause chemical reactions, such as fluorescence. UVC, which can be ionizing, doesn't normally reach earth's surface.
UV light causes reactive oxygen species, I guess this is not the same as ionizing.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reactive_oxygen_species
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3709783/
(EDIT: more responses have been added by others that echo this information)
So maybe part of the issue is that "UV" or "Microwave" are too broad as categories to make a statement like "Microwaves are totally safe"
Microwaves have very low photon energy far below any mechanism known to cause non-thermal effects. RF can heat you based on power absorption that is all.
UV: 3eV to 124eV
RF: .00001eV
Alpha or beta particles damages DNA by breaking chemical bonds in the DNA backbone or bases, leading to single-strand breaks or more severe damage.
Gamma rays can directly ionize atoms, leading to the formation of free radicals and other reactive species. These free radicals can damage DNA by causing single-strand and double-strand breaks, base modifications, and other types of chemical damage.
Non-ionizing radiation can also damage DNA, in a number of different ways. UV radiation damages DNA in four different ways:
1) Thymine Dimers Formation: One of the most common types of UV-induced DNA damage is the formation of thymine dimers. In DNA, thymine (one of the four nucleotide bases) absorbs UV radiation and becomes excited. In this excited state, it can react with an adjacent thymine base on the same strand, forming a covalent bond between them. This creates a thymine dimer, which is a distortion in the normal DNA structure. Thymine dimers can disrupt the DNA replication and transcription processes, leading to genetic mutations if not properly repaired.
2) DNA Strand Breaks: UV radiation can also cause breaks in the sugar-phosphate backbone of the DNA molecule. These breaks can occur directly due to the energy of the UV radiation or indirectly through the formation of reactive oxygen species. DNA strand breaks can interfere with DNA replication and repair mechanisms.
3) Formation of Cyclobutane Pyrimidine Dimers (CPDs): CPDs are a specific type of thymine dimer that forms when two adjacent pyrimidine bases (usually thymine) become covalently bonded. These dimers create a kink in the DNA structure, causing distortion and affecting the proper functioning of DNA enzymes.
4) Oxidative Damage: UV radiation can lead to the production of reactive oxygen species within cells. These highly reactive molecules can damage DNA and other cellular components by causing oxidative stress.
There could be ways non-UV, non-ionizing radiation can damage DNA as well, and studies such as this one explore that idea.
There is no know non-thermal mechanism which RF can cause DNA damage and you did not seem to present one, only that the photon energy of UV is high enough to cause photo chemical effects that RF simply cannot do.
Good grief, what's with all the people confidently lumping UV and RF together? This is not a small distinction, a tiny fudge factor, a little oopsie-doodle. We are talking completely different ball games in completely different parks in different countries speaking different languages. The photon energies (and, therefore, the direct effects on matter) are wildly different. Would you rather be hit by a penny or hit by a car?
UV: 3eV
RF: .00001eV
Germans seem to have a particular concern about EM radiation when compared to other countries. I don't really understand why.