I'm surprised government-owned devices are allowed any non-essential apps at all.
E.g. the story about government / military facilities being exposed via army using Strava to track running routes (effectively creating a map of the facility)
I'm surprised government-owned devices are allowed any non-essential apps at all.
E.g. the story about government / military facilities being exposed via army using Strava to track running routes (effectively creating a map of the facility)
Regardless, as an employee, putting social media on your subpoena-able and hopefully defeatured work device is a bad idea.
Good! People are free to purchase a personal phone and do whatever they want on their personal device.
There are three concerns here:
Concern 1: Government employees being paid to do work, but instead spending time on TikTok. -- yes, a 2nd device makes this worse, but certainly banning government devices are a necessary (though not sufficient) step here.
Concern 2: Confidential government data obtained by apps with broad permissions -- solved by moving TikTok off government device and onto personal device, as the personal device shouldnt have government data on it (e.g., tax records, health records, personal records of citizens)
Concern 3: ALL data exposed to foreign governments via TikTok and other apps - still, banning government devices are a necessary (though not sufficient) step here. NYC doesnt have jurisdiction over all citizen behaviors, and this needs to be decided federally realistically.
Now, if the 2nd decide is a government device also, then no problem! TikTok is already banned on the 2nd device also. As will be for the 3rd and 4th government device.
If the 2nd device is a personal device with government documents, you have a much different problem of why that is the case.
For what it's worth, as far as I recall from when I was in the military, which is getting to be a while ago but at least Facebook existed, social media apps were definitely not allowed on government-issued mobile devices. Unit PR offices did maintain Facebook pages, but those were updated from PCs using the web interface, not via app. I guess it's a small consideration, but something to consider for companies that decide to release some web service only as an app.
However, one thought I had is that you want to make sure government business happens on government phones, and maybe people are less likely to do that if they habitually using their personal phones during the work day? I'm not saying that was the calculation, just thinking this through.
Probably better to have 1 phone that’s semi-restricted.
Maybe phones should have a hypervisor and multiple VMs (or VPs?) to support this without having to cart around additional hardware.
This is more like people with fitbits or other activity tracking devices, not their government-provided devices. I mean the only way to make it not show up is to ban ALL devices (personal and otherwise).