Why would we want cache file in our home directory when we have a /var directory for this kind of stuff and especially a /var/tmp directory which has the sticky bit ? Who decided that cramming stuff into ~/.cache was a good idea instead of putting it in /var/tmp/usercache-<username> directory?
Why would we want a .config and .local directories full of binaries, artifacts and config files within our documents when we have /usr/local for that? Put that into /usr/local/<username> instead!
And then comes the terrible folder list:
Desktop : this one is largely unused by me, why putting icons in a screen when they will be mostly obscured by windows while I am using my computer? Do we have to replicate all bad ideas of Windows?
Documents : this one is okayish, but why isn't my whole homedir a documents homedir if we can clean it up from all the config, binaries and cache shit eh? Aren't Pictures, Music, Videos or what I download documents too?
Downloads : that one may be useful, although /tmp would be more interesting to me. For the most part if I don't use the files I download immediately I will never look for them or they will be possibly obsolete by the time I find them. It forces me to do housekeeping while having them in /tmp would clean the shit at next reboot.
Music: ok I suppose but nowadays lots of people are using streaming, I mean I can create it myself if I want to.
Pictures: this one is stupid, why is a picture not a 'document' and why would we need to separate it? What do I do if I want to put pictures asset in my markdown document? Should I point it to some obscure directory here or should I put it in myproject/assets/ ? OK some would argue this is a good place to auto import your photos from your camera but wait. If one day I use digikam but then I later decide it is not so great and want to use something else it is likely to make a mess.
Public: most people never use that. It is for file sharing purpose I reckon but it can be created whenever you need to by the 0.2% of people who will use it.
Templates: same as public, people are never that organized and will rarely put templates there instead of next to their docs. I never saw any app making use of that, most of the builtin templates are provided with the package and are stored in /usr/local
Videos: same stupidity as Pictures. My Videos ARE documents. Besides, what if I want to keep the videos of one event or my vacations next to the Photos? Why would I want videos of my kids playing on the beach be next to regular movies, porn, videos from a sports event I participated at or screen recordings?
All these folders are meant to target a majority of users but in the end create a fake sense of organization that doesn't really work for anyone, everybody end up having files everywhere and/or only partially following those conventions which end up with the same mess as having just the regular mess /home/<username> or /usr/local/home/<username>