I don't play favorites and I've found Amazon consignment to be a reasonable source of high reliability delivery, but I've been burned before as I watch things cross from the far side of the country slowly to arrive at the edge of the date window. When it arrives past the window Amazon is always good and quick on refunds, that is good MIS.
But I will also scan down list and choose a 3rd party seller that is a little more expensive IF it is close to me geographically and promises to ship small items by USPS. USPS has always done right by me, probably because I avoid living in or near big cities.