Illinois State Tax Revenues Drop Following Affiliate Nexus Tax
hasoffers.com
hasoffers.com
This is especially true given that use tax is almost entirely, without this law, paid by end users as part of income tax collection, and so trying to break revenues down by month is inane: not everyone bothers filing estimated payments, especially if they are part of a payroll system that does withholding for them. They are going to report use tax once during the year, and it is going to be in April.
Same here, inventing new taxes doesn't increase taxes (that much). It increases the incentive and energy expended on finding ways to avoid your new tax.
The record and movie industries are indeed wrong in their belief that every pirated copy represents a lost sale, but you are erring in the other direction.
First, aside from people who are pirating a movie they don't know much about to try it out, generally people aren't pirating movies that they think are crap. It wastes their time, and if they have a bandwidth cap wastes their limited bandwidth.
Second, most pirates, at least in the developed world, do have discretionary money for entertainment and other luxuries. If they could not pirate movies, the would most likely not give them up. They would reallocate their discretionary entertainment money so that they could get some movies.
If a perfect anti-piracy technology were deployed, there would be two competing effects.
1. Many people would reallocate discretionary spending. The movie industry would gain. Restaurants, game companies, book publishers, fashion, and such would lose.
2. Piracy can serve to raise awareness of a movie, which increases demand among non-pirates. If piracy were stopped, the movie industry might have to raise advertising spends.
I think it would make most people's lives that much simpler.
A person who makes $10M a year spends a much lower percentage of his income than someone who makes $40K a year. So now we're taxing the $40K person heavily, while the $10M person pays comparatively almost nothing, even accounting for lavish and expensive lifestyles.
It reinforces a negative cycle - the rich get richer, the poor get poorer, and social mobility is removed. When the poor lose all hope of improving their lot because the system is so stacked against them, instability and unrest results and... well, the rest of this story might get a little violent.
This is probably a worse idea than, say, the flat-rate income tax that is practiced in Hong Kong and elsewhere.
A sales tax can vary depending on the type of good. Luxury goods can be more taxed than essential goods. Wouldn't this even the playing field?
You can have luxury taxes, but it's hard to match income tax if your goal is to have a fairly progressive tax.
The rich secretly like the progressive tax code and all the exemptions. The thicker the tax code the more loop-holes for them.