As for the logic behind half rather than all:
1. Revoking a permit is a drastic action that could cause cruise to leave the DMVs regulatory area entirely and go to another state like Arizona with essentially no oversight.
2. It could open them up to legal action that would consume lots of money for essentially no purpose
3. It gets the incident rate down so the situation is less political while the investigation is ongoing.
Of course, this is absurd. Instead, we slap on some caveats (time/passenger restrictions) and accept the risk with the knowledge the driver will improve with time.
This is exactly the same for self driving vehicles. The only way to make them safer for public roads is to drive them on public roads. So if we slap on some caveats, such as a reduced fleet, we can make them safer while keeping incidents down.
Although, I didn't mean that a zero incidence rate should be the rule, more like, if one knows a system is defective, also in such a dangerous context, it'd be negligent to still ship it under the pretense of a "low incidence rate".
It's easy to imagine that a 50% reduction in fleet size could make this 90% less likely, while they work on ways to prevent that from happening again.
It's not just about the behavior of any individual robotaxi, but it's also about their behavior collectively.
It's also not just about safety, but about being a public nuisance -- if they break down or get confused too often. We can tolerate a small overall amount of that in a city, but not a large overall amount. It's not binary.