This view is alienating systems programmers. You're right that that's what the standard says, but nobody actually wants that except compiler writers trying to juice unrealistic benchmarks. In practice programmers want to alias things, they want to access unaligned memory, they want to cast objects right out of memory without constructing them, etc. And they have real reasons to do so! More narrowly defining how off the rails the compiler is allowed to go, rather than anything is a desirable objective for changing the standard.