Hacker News Reader

Comment by darkteflon | Hacker News Reader

Can this be triggered with a keyboard shortcut? The video seems to imply that you can’t.

Edit: Disappointed to see that the Pro plan is on a subscription basis.

I don't know what happened to the macOS app ecosystem where most tools go with the one time payment model instead of subscription.

It is not sustainable for indie devs and the software suffers as a result.

superwhisper is not expensive (65 a year) given what it provides to the user.

On top of that the base features are free, and require absolutely nothing from you, no sign up or contact information required at all- just download and use.

It completely respects your personal privacy and provides a useful service. Very few tools outside of open source do this.

Death by 1000 $65/year apps and services.

Sorry but because everything is a subscription it’s harder and harder to justify adding another on the stack.

It's very annoying that everything is going to the monthly subs BS and I can't just pay $5 for 1000 widget bazingas or whatever the credit system is called.

It's almost like developers need to feed their families.

If the new features are worth it, I will pay to upgrade. If they aren't why am I paying yearly?

It’s a bit of a strange argument that developers can feed their families _only_ if they sell their software on a subscription basis. Nobody wants to developers to starve. At the same time it is not a _duty_ of users of a software to make sure the developer’s family is fed. It is a business. Developer sells something, and the buyer gets value in return. Subscription is just one way of making the buyer pay more(may be hoping that they forget that they were paying for it amidst 50 other subscriptions). It is perfectly fine to say “I expect to feed my family with this work. So I want to charge $bigamount”. Then your buyers chose whether your software is worth that or not.

You may also say, “I prefer a recurring income, and don’t want to charge one time. It is my prerogative.”, but arguing that one cannot feed their families any other way is disingenuous.

Another way of looking at it is - software is not very different than ebooks. Imagine if an author of a book says “Books should only be sold as subscription. It’s almost as if my readers don’t want me to feed my family!” If every reader is not continuously paying me $5/month, how can I keep learning and providing little updates to this book, and make errata?! How dare they try to get my knowledge at once when they can be paying me so much more to keep me fed?!

Perhaps I am misinterpreting feedback of "offer a lifetime deal" as "give me it for less".

Would help to know, what would you pay for it? What do you think its worth?

It is your product. You alone have the power to set a price. You may want to do market research to figure what the users would like to pay for it, but you can still decide to go higher or lower than that outcome.

I’m perfectly fine with a software product that is on the expensive side if it justifies its value to me as a user. This particular product I don’t have a professional use for, and cannot give you a number value.

Based on this feedback added a lifetime license option.

https://superwhisperapp.lemonsqueezy.com/checkout?cart=856e7...

Due to popular demand, decided to add a Lifetime license option.

https://superwhisperapp.lemonsqueezy.com/checkout?cart=856e7...

100%, you can configure which keyboard shortcut you want to use in settings as well- check out the image linked below.

https://imgur.com/a/LXlwy7F

Okay I see - perhaps the interface shown in the video is out of date.

It’s a cool little app, I’d be happy to pay a few dollars for something like this, but not a subscription.

Fair enough! Theres a very generous free tier (both small and base models enabled) that should cover a basic use case.

Justification for charging a subscription is value based:

65 bucks a year is not a lot to spend if it saves you 10+ hours of time typing, and editing your messages. Dictating is joyful and saves me time each day. superwhisper spells/punctuates better and writes faster than I can with a keyboard.

This alongside the cost to me, 10s of hours each week of my time as the solo developer go into:

• Supporting users with their issues and bugs fixes

• Continuing to update the app with new features (4 major features released this month alone)

• Making sure you have access to the latest features and capabilities as AI advances.

Also, keep in mind, with free / cheap solutions: "If you are not paying for it, you're the product".

Fair enough, it’s 100% your product to price how you see fit. I do think you’re shooting yourself in the foot a bit, though. But best of luck to you! The free version is great, keep up the good work.

Thanks! I hope at some point you find it useful enough to justify the price.

I have a gripe with voice dictation apps.

I found this back a decade or more ago when I saw windows 7 had an inbuilt voice recognition.

Before that I had an old copy of dragon on xp or 98 I think but the problem remained.

I want this. >>

I want to say a sentence. The computer would understand and speak it back to me. Yes. Then I would say a sentence. It says a word wrong. Scratch that. I say the whole line again.

It may sound repetive but it "should" work because every dictation software expects user to monitor the screen and fix errors that way. If I am reading the screen, I might as well use a keyboard.

I want this full screen-less voice dictation experience by sitting in a comfy blanket, eyes closed and just letting words flow.

Anything else and I would rather just use the keyboard as I said.

A push-to-talk option would be a fine addition for something like this, let you fire off single sentences quickly.

Interesting, could implement this as an option. Out of curiosity what would you map it to on your keyboard?

I would make it just use the same hotkey, but held down. So in the default case, tapping option-space would start a normal recording session, tapping again would stop it; holding option-space down would start a PTT session, releasing would end it.

PTT would be such a naturally good fit here imo.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com