This is just reiterating my entire point. People follow the rule/strict interpretation of the law and SemVer breaks, you should be following the spirit of the law.
This is just reiterating my entire point. People follow the rule/strict interpretation of the law and SemVer breaks, you should be following the spirit of the law.
> A massive UI overhaul (but without breaking features) is almost definitely a major version bump
as I think effect of UI changes tends to be underestimated. Just because v1 & v2 both have a button to frobnicate doesn't mean that they are equal. If v1 had a big large frobnicator in the main screen, and v2 buried it in a menu, you could say that no feature was broken, but the user interaction is very different.
That sort of change often gets rolled into a minor/patch bump, but it does break workflows. However if every change like that bumped the major version, it would be noise. There would be no way to judge the scale of the changes from v9 to v23 vs v14 to v16.
I'm not sure if the spirit of the law of SemVer applies here though. The type of change is not important, only how much has changed. Bugs can be features.
If yes then I agree that it's a good guideline, but I don't think that's really "semver" at that point.